No-Bake Pumpkin Cheesecake
No-bake pumpkin cheesecake

Ready for a delicious no-bake pumpkin cheesecake recipe? While fall begins at the end of September, we don’t really start to see the change of seasons until October. The Blue Ridge Mountains light up with a rainbow of oranges, yellows, and reds. The summer mugginess begins to fade, and the fall breeze — just a hint of winter — begins wafting through our campus. 

There are so many fall activities to fill up your calendar like apple picking, trick or treating, pumpkin carving, and, of course, baking! Autumn baking produces some of our favorite seasonal treats like pumpkin rolls, applesauce cookies, and pecan pie. We wanted to challenge ourselves this year by creating a no-bake version of one of our favorite desserts — pumpkin cheesecake. 

It’s starting to feel like fall here in Central Virginia, and we’ve been craving something special: no-bake pumpkin cheesecake. 

No-Bake Pumpkin Cheesecake Recipe

We love cooking and baking here at Emerson Creek Pottery, but it’s hard to find time to bake a cheesecake. Between baking time and chilling time, it can take an entire afternoon to make a cheesecake. This no-bake cheesecake recipe from Sally’s Baking Addiction simplifies the process without compromising on flavor. 

Everything from the crust to the pumpkin pie filling is homemade, and it only takes 20 minutes to prepare. Assemble this cake in just a few minutes before work and come home to a perfect no-bake pumpkin cheesecake!

Why We Love This Recipe

First and foremost, we love this no-bake pumpkin cheesecake recipe because of how easy it is. It takes just 20 minutes to make something that tastes like it took 2 hours or more. 

We also like that this recipe uses homemade crust. While most recipes can be adapted to include a homemade crust, we’ve found that most no-bake cheesecake recipes call for a pre-made pie crust. While these types of crusts are convenient, they aren’t always as tasty as homemade crusts, and they come with lots of disposable packaging like an aluminum pie pan and a plastic lid to cover leftovers. 

Using a recipe with a homemade crust allowed us to make this delicious cheesecake in one of our stoneware bakers. While we do have a pie plate made especially for pies, our BROOKLINE Baker was the perfect vessel for this recipe. The sides of our pie plates are sloped like a traditional pie pan, but the sides of the BROOKLINE Baker are straight, resembling a springform pan. 

How Our Cheesecake Turned Out

While the recipe calls for a gingersnap crust, we opted for a traditional graham cracker crust — found in the Perfect No-Bake Cheesecake recipe from the same author — because we couldn’t find gingersnaps at Aldi. (We’re avid Aldi shoppers here at Emerson Creek Pottery.) 

The graham cracker crust is fun to make and mixes up easily. To create graham cracker crumbs, we put whole graham crackers in a gallon-sized zipper bag and smacked them with a rolling pin. Once the crackers were broken up into relatively small chunks, we rolled them out until they were nice and crumbly. 

The cheesecake filling tasted great on its own — like a pumpkin pudding — but it tasted even better in the graham cracker crust! 

To make it look pretty, we added some decorations — whipping topping, chocolate nibs, and more graham cracker crumbs.

Overall, this recipe was fun and easy to make. We think the graham cracker crust may have needed to have been baked to help it stick together a bit better, but the flavor was fantastic. We will definitely be making this recipe again!

About the BROOKLINE Baker

We used our BROOKLINE Baker in Ivory to make this recipe. You can purchase the same baker here or choose from all of our glazes here

Part of our new BROOKLINE collection, the BROOKLINE Baker is the jack-of-all bakeware. Its 1.5-quart capacity makes it an excellent vessel for quiche, nachos, and, of course, cheesecakes. Most recipes that call for a 9-inch round cake pan work well in this baker — We argue that they turn out better in our stoneware baker than in a traditional aluminum cake pan. Our custom stoneware clay formula evenly distributes heat and gives you the perfect bake every time!

Leave a Reply

Put Something New On The Table

Recipe posts

Summertime Peanut Shortbread

Summertime Peanut Shortbread

Guest Post from Lucy Natkiel of Brown Bag Designs. Creator of Brown Bag Shortbread Pans and Cookie Molds. I’m retired. I keep telling people that. But the information seems to bounce right off of several shortbread aficionados I know. Particularly my friend Rox. “I neeeeed

Read More »
Spicy Shortbread Recipe

Spicy Shortbread Recipe

We are so excited to announce that we will be sharing one shortbread recipe each month from the Gourmet Brown Bag Cookie Art Shortbread Book. These recipes are designed specifically for our shortbread pans, which come in 20 beautiful designs! Last month, we shared a

Read More »
Stoneware Ceramic Shortbread pan with Shortbread cookies

Martha Stewart Uses Our Shortbread Pans

We’re excited to have our Shortbread Pans featured yet again by Martha Stewart! While all of our Brown Bag Designs Shortbread Pans come with a book of recipes designed specifically for our pans, third-party shortbread recipes work in our pans as well. Martha Stewart uses

Read More »